Method and system for secure cable modem registration6170061Abstract A method and system for secure cable modem initialization in a data-over-cable system is provided. The method includes sending a unique identifier, such an Internet Protocol ("IP") address and a selected time-value, such as an approximate message send time-value, in a registration request message. A message integrity check value is calculated using the unique identifier, the selected time-value and one or more configuration parameters in a pre-determined order. The message integrity check value is added to the registration request message. A cable modem termination system receives the registration request message and uses the message integrity check value to authenticate the message and determine if the registration request message was sent within a pre-determined period of time (e.g., 1 second) from a recognized cable modem. If not, the registration request message is discarded and a log file entry is added to a log file with information from the registration request message (e.g., network level and data-link level network addresses). The network address and selected time-value uniquely identify the cable modem and help prevent a rouge user from intercepting a valid cable modem registration request message and using it at a later time to register a rouge cable modem. The log file helps track rouge users attacking the data-over-cable system. The method and system provide improved security for registering cable modems in a data-over-cable system. Claims I claim: Description FIELD OF INVENTION
TABLE 1
SPD 74 Parameter Description
Factory Default Flag Boolean value, if TRUE(1), indicates a
SPD which should be used by CM 16.
Service Provider Name This parameter includes the name of a
service provider. Format is standard
ASCII string composed of numbers and
letters.
Telephone Numbers These parameters contain telephone
numbers that CM 16 uses to initiate a
telephony modem link during a login
process. Connections are attempted in
ascending numeric order (i.e., Phone
Number 1, Phone Number 2 . . .). The SPD
contains a valid telephony dial string as
the primary dial string (Phone Number 1),
secondary dial-strings are optional.
Format is ASCII string(s) composed of:
any sequence of numbers, pound "#" and
star "*" keys and comma character ","
used to indicate a two second pause in
dialing.
Connection Threshold The number of sequential connection
failures before indicating connection
failure. A dial attempt that does not result
in an answer and connection after no
more than ten rings is considered a
failure. The default value is one.
Login User Name This contains a user name CM 16 will use
an authentication protocol over the
telephone link during the initialization
procedure. Format is a monolithic
sequence of alphanumeric characters in
an ASCII string composed of numbers
and letters.
Login Password This contains a password that CM 16 will
use during authentication over a
telephone link during the initialization
procedure. Format is a monolithic
sequence of alphanumeric characters in
an ASCII string composed of numbers
and letters.
DHCP Authenticate Boolean value, reserved to indicate that
CM 16 uses a specific indicated DHCP 66
Server (see next parameter) for a DHCP
66 Client and BOOTP Relay Process
when TRUE (one). The default is FALSE
(zero) which allows any DHCP 66 Server.
DHCP Server IP 54 address value of a DHCP 66 Server
CM 16 uses for DHCP 66 Client and
BOOTP Relay Process. If this attribute is
present and DHCP 66 Authenticate
attribute is TRUE(1). The default value is
integer zero.
RADIUS Realm The realm name is a string that defines a
RADIUS server domain. Format is a
monolithic sequence of alphanumeric
characters in an ACSII string composed
of numbers and letters.
PPP Authentication This parameter instructs the telephone
modem which authentication procedure to
perform over the telephone link.
Demand Dial Timer This parameter indicates time (in
seconds) of inactive networking time that
will be allowed to elapse before hanging
up a telephone connection at CM 16. If
this optional parameter is not present, or
set to zero, then the demand dial feature
is not activated. The default value is zero.
Vendor Specific Extensions Optional vendor specific extensions.
A Termination System Information ("TSI") message is transmitted by CMTS 12 at periodic intervals (e.g., every 2 seconds) to report CMTS 12 information to CM 16 whether or not telephony return is used. The TSI message is transmitted as a MAC 44 management message. The TSI provides a CMTS 12 boot record in a downstream channel to CM 16 via cable network 14. Information in the TSI is used by CM 16 to obtain information about the status of CMTS 12. The TSI message has a MAC 44 management type value of TRI_TSI. FIG. 4 is a block diagram of a TSI message structure 76. TSI message structure 76 includes a MAC 44 management header 78, a downstream channel IP address 80, a registration IP address 82, a CMTS 12 boot time 84, a downstream channel identifier 86, an epoch time 88 and vendor specific TLV encoded data 90. A description of the fields of TSI message 76 are shown in Table 2. However, more or fewer fields could also be used in TSI message 76.
TABLE 2
TSI 76 Parameter Description
Downstream Channel This field contains an IP 54 address of
IP Address 80 CMTS 12 available on the downstream
channel this message arrived on
Registration IP Address 82 This field contains an IP 54 address
CM 16 sends its registration request
messages to. This address MAY be
the same as the Downstream Channel
IP 54 address.
CMTS Boot Time 84 Specifies an absolute-time of a CMTS
12 recorded epoch. The clock setting
for this epoch uses the current clock
time with an unspecified accuracy.
Time is represented as a 32 bit binary
number.
Downstream Channel ID 86 A downstream channel on which this
message has been transmitted. This
identifier is arbitrarily chosen by CMTS
12 and is unique within the MAC 44
layer.
Epoch 88 An integer value that is incremented
each time CMTS 12 is either re-
initialized or performs address or
routing table flush.
Vendor Specific Extensions 90 Optional vendor extensions may be
added as TLV encoded data.
After receiving TCD 70 message and TSI message 76, CM 16 continues to establish access to data network 28 (and resources on the network) by first dialing into TRAC 24 and establishing a telephony PPP 50 session. Upon the completion of a successful PPP 50 connection, CM 16 performs PPP Link Control Protocol ("LCP") negotiation with TRAC 24. Once LCP negotiation is complete, CM 16 requests Internet Protocol Control Protocol ("IPCP") address negotiation. For more information on IPCP see RFC-1332 incorporated herein by reference. During IPCP negotiation, CM 16 negotiates an IP 54 address with TRAC 24 for sending IP 54 data packet responses back to data network 28 via TRAC 24. When CM 16 has established an IP 54 link to TRAC 24, it begins "upstream" communications to CMTS 12 via DHCP layer 66 to complete a virtual data connection by attempting to discover network host interfaces available on CMTS 12 (e.g., IP 54 host interfaces for a virtual IP 54 connection). The virtual data connection allows CM 16 to receive data from data network 28 via CMTS 12 and cable network 14, and send return data to data network 28 via TRAC 24 and PSTN 22. CM 16 must first determine an address of a host interface (e.g., an IP 54 interface) available on CMTS 12 that can be used by data network 28 to send data to CM 16. However, CM 16 has only a downstream connection from CMTS 12 and has to obtain a connection address to data network 28 using an upstream connection to TRAC 24. Addressing Network Host Interfaces In The Data-Over-Cable System Via The Cable Modem FIG. 5 is a flow diagram illustrating a method 92 for addressing network host interfaces in a data-over-cable system with telephony return via a cable modem. Method 92 allows a cable modem to establish a virtual data connection to a data network. In method 92, multiple network devices are connected to a first network with a downstream connection of a first connection type, and connected to a second network with an upstream connection of a second connection type. The first and second networks are connected to a third network with a third connection type. At step 94, a selection input is received on a first network device from the first network over the downstream connection. The selection input includes a first connection address allowing the first network device to communicate with the first network via upstream connection to the second network. At step 96, a first message of a first type for a first protocol is created on the first network device having the first connection address from the selection input in a first message field. The first message is used to request a network host interface address on the first network. The first connection address allows the first network device to have the first message with the first message type forwarded to network host interfaces available on the first network via the upstream connection to the second network. At step 98, the first network device sends the first message over the upstream connection to the second network. The second network uses the first address field in the first message to forward the first message to one or more network host interfaces available on first network at step 100. Network host interfaces available on the first network that can provide the services requested in first message send a second message with a second message type with a second connection address in a second message field to the first network at step 102. The second connection address allows the first network device to receive data packets from the third network via a network host interface available on the first network. The first network forwards one or more second messages on the downstream connection to the first network device at step 104. The first network device selects a second connection address from one of the second messages from one of the one or more network host interfaces available on the first network at step 106 and establishes a virtual connection from the third network to the first network device using the second connection address for the selected network host interface. The virtual connection includes receiving data on the first network host interface on the first network from the third network and sending the data over the downstream connection to the first network device. The first network device sends data responses back to the third network over the upstream connection to the second network, which forwards the data to the appropriate destination on the third network. In one embodiment of the present invention, the data-over-cable system is data-over-cable system 10, the first network device is CM 16, the first network is cable television network 14, the downstream connection is a cable television connection. The second network is PSTN 22, the upstream connection is a telephony connection, the third network is data network 28 (e.g., the Internet or an intranet) and the third type of connection is an IP 54 connection. The first and second connection addresses are IP 54 addresses. However, the present invention is not limited to the network components and addresses described. Method 92 allows CM 16 to determine an IP 54 network host interface address available on CMTS 12 to receive IP 54 data packets from data network 28, thereby establishing a virtual IP 54 connection with data network 28. After addressing network host interfaces using method 92, an exemplary data path through cable system 10 is illustrated in Table 3. However other data paths could also be used and the present invention is not limited to the data paths shown in Table 3. For example, CM 16 may send data upstream back through cable network 14 (e.g., CM 16 to cable network 14 to CMTS 12) and not use PSTN 22 and the telephony return upstream path.
TABLE 3
1. An IP 54 datagram from data network 28 destined for CM 16 arrives on
CMTS-NSI 32 and
enters CMTS 12.
2. CMTS 12 encodes the IP 54 datagram in a cable data frame, passes it to
MAC 44 and
transmits it "downstream" to RF interface 40 on CM 16 via cable
network 14
3. CM 16 recognizes the encoded IP 54 datagram in MAC layer 44 received
via. RF interface 40.
4. CM 16 responds to the cable data frame and encapsulates a response IP
54 datagram in a
PPP 50 frame and transmits it "upstream" with modem interface 48 via
PSTN 22 to TRAC 24.
5. TRAC 24 decodes the IP 54 datagram and forwards it via TRAC-NSI 30 to
a destination on
data network 28.
Dynamic Network Host Configuration On Data-Over-Cable System As was illustrated in FIG. 2, CM 16 includes a Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol ("DHCP") layer 66, hereinafter DHCP 66. DHCP 66 is used to provide configuration parameters to hosts on a network (e.g., an IP 54 network). DHCP 66 consists of two components: a protocol for delivering host-specific configuration parameters from a DHCP 66 server to a host and a mechanism for allocation of network host addresses to hosts. DHCP 66 is built on a client-server model, where designated DHCP 66 servers allocate network host addresses and deliver configuration parameters to dynamically configured network host clients. FIG. 6 is a block diagram illustrating a DHCP 66 message structure 108. The format of DHCP 66 messages is based on the format of BOOTstrap Protocol ("BOOTP") messages described in RFC-951 and RFC-1542 incorporated herein by reference. From a network host client's point of view, DHCP 66 is an extension of the BOOTP mechanism. This behavior allows existing BOOTP clients to interoperate with DHCP 66 servers without requiring any change to network host the clients' BOOTP initialization software. DHCP 66 provides persistent storage of network parameters for network host clients. To capture BOOTP relay agent behavior described as part of the BOOTP specification and to allow interoperability of existing BOOTP clients with DHCP 66 servers, DHCP 66 uses a BOOTP message format. Using BOOTP relaying agents eliminates the necessity of having a DHCP 66 server on each physical network segment. DHCP 66 message structure 108 includes an operation code field 110 ("op"), a hardware address type field 112 ("htype"), a hardware address length field 114 ("hlen"), a number of hops field 116 ("hops"), a transaction identifier field 118 ("xid"), a seconds elapsed time field 120 ("secs"), a flags field 122 ("flags"), a client IP address field 124 ("ciaddr"), a your IP address field 126 ("yiaddr"), a server IP address field 128 ("siaddr"), a gateway/relay agent IP address field 130 ("giaddr"), a client hardware address field 132 ("chaddr"), an optional server name field 134 ("sname"), a boot file name 136 ("file") and an optional parameters field 138 ("options"). Descriptions for DHCP 66 message 108 fields are shown in Table 4.
TABLE 4
DCHP 66
Parameter Description
OP 110 Message op code/message type.
1 BOOTREQUEST, 2 = BOOTREPLY.
HTYPE 112 Hardware address type (e.g., `1` = 10
Mps Ethernet).
HLEN 114 Hardware address length (e.g. `6` for 10
Mbps Ethernet).
HOPS 116 Client sets to zero, optionally used by
relay-agents when booting via a relay-
agent.
XID 118 Transaction ID, a random number
chosen by the client, used by the client
and server to associate messages and
responses between a client and a
server.
SECS 120 Filled in by client, seconds elapsed
since client started trying to boot.
FLAGS 122 Flags including a BROADCAST bit.
CIADDR 124 Client IP address; filled in by client in
DHCPREQUEST if verifying previously
allocated configu ration parameters.
YIADDR 126 `Your` (client) IP address.
SIADDR 128 IP 54 address of next server to use in
bootstrap; returned in DHCPOFFER,
DHCPACK and DHCPNAK by server.
GIADDR 130 Gateway relay agent IP 54 address,
used in booting via a relay-agent.
CHADDR Client hardware address (e.g., MAC
132 layer 44 address).
SNAME 134 Optional server host name, null
terminated string.
FILE 136 Boot file name, terminated by a null
string.
OPTIONS Optional parameters.
138
The DHCP 66 message structure shown in FIG. 6 is used to discover IP 54 and other network host interfaces in data-over-cable system 10. A network host client (e.g., CM 16) uses DHCP 66 to acquire or verify an IP 54 address and network parameters whenever the network parameters may have changed. Table 5 illustrates a typical use of the DHCP 66 protocol to discover a network host interface from a network host client.
TABLE 5
1. A network host client broadcasts a DHCP 66 discover message on its
local physical subnet.
The DHCP 66 discover message may include options that suggest values
for a network host
interface address. BOOTP relay agents may pass the message on to DHCP
66 servers not
on the same physical subnet.
2. DHCP servers may respond with a DHCPOFFER message that includes an
available
network address in the `yiaddr` field (and other configuration
parameters in DHCP 66 options)
from a network host interface. DHCP 66 servers unicasts the DHCPOFFER
message to the
network host client (using the DHCPIBOOTP relay agent if necessary) if
possible, or may
broadcast the message to a broadcast address (preferably
255.255.255.255) on the client's
subnet.
3. The network host client receives one or more DHCPOFFER messages from
one or more
DHCP 66 servers. The network host client may choose to wait for
multiple responses.
4. The network host client chooses one DHCP 66 server with an associated
network host
interface from which to request configuration parameters, based on the
configuration
parameters offered in the DHCPOFFER messages.
Discovering Network Host Interfaces In The Data-Over-Cable System The DHCP discovery process illustrated in table 5 will not work in data-over-cable system 10. CM 16 has only a downstream connection from CMTS 12, which includes DHCP 66 servers, associated with network host interfaces available on CMTS 12. In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, CM 16 discovers network host interfaces via TRAC 24 and PSTN 22 on an upstream connection. The DHCP 66 addressing process shown in Table 5 was not originally intended to discover network host interfaces in data-over-cable system 10. CMTS 12 has DHCP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces (e.g., IP interfaces), but CM 16 only has as downstream connection from CMTS 12. CM 16 has an upstream connection to TRAC 24, which has a DHCP 66 layer. However, TRAC 24 does not have DHCP 66 servers, or direct access to network host interfaces on CMTS 12. FIGS. 7A and 7B are a flow diagram illustrating a method 140 for discovering network host interfaces in data-over-cable system 10. When CM 16 has established an IP 54 link to TRAC 24, it begins communications with CMTS 12 via DHCP 66 to complete a virtual IP 54 connection with data network 28. However, to discover what IP 54 host interfaces might be available on CMTS 12, CM 16 has to communicate with CMTS 12 via PSTN 22 and TRAC 24 since CM 16 only has a "downstream" cable channel from CMTS 12. At step 142 in FIG. 7A, after receiving a TSI message 76 from CMTS 12 on a downstream connection, CM 16 generates a DHCP discover ("DHCPDISCOVER") message and sends it upstream via PSTN 22 to TRAC 22 to discover what IP 54 interfaces are available on CMTS 12. The fields of the DHCP discover message are set as illustrated in Table 6. However, other field settings may also be used.
TABLE 6
DCHP 66
Parameter Description
OP 110 Set to BOOTREQUEST.
HTYPE 112 Set to network type (e.g., one for 10 Mbps
Ethernet).
HLEN 114 Set to network length (e.g., six for 10 Mbps
Ethernet)
HOPS 116 Set to zero.
FLAGS 118 Set BROADCAST bit to zero.
CIADDR 124 If CM 16 has previously been assigned an IP
54 address, the IP 54 address is placed in this
field. If CM 16 has previously been assigned
an IP 54 address by DHCP 66, and also has
been assigned an address via IPCP, CM 16
places the DHCP 66 IP 54 address in this
field.
GIADDR 130 CM 16 places the Downstream Channel IP 54
address 80 of CMTS 12 obtained in TSI
message 76 on a cable downstream channel
in this field.
CHADDR 132 CM 16 places its 48-bit MAC 44 LAN address
in this field.
The DHCPDISCOVER message is used to "discover" the existence of one or more IP 54 host interfaces available on CMTS 12. DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 (FIG. 6) includes the downstream channel IP address 80 of CMTS 12 obtained in TSI message 76 (e.g., the first message field from step 96 of method 92). Using the downstream channel IP address 80 of CMTS 12 obtained in TSI message 76 allows the DHCPDISCOVER message to be forwarded by TRAC 24 to DHCP 66 servers (i.e., protocol servers) associated with network host interfaces available on CMTS 12. If DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 (FIG. 6) in a DHCP message from a DHCP 66 client is non-zero, the DHCP 66 server sends any return messages to a DHCP 66 server port on a DHCP 66 relaying agent (e.g., CMTS 12) whose address appears in DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130. In a typical DHCP 66 discovery process the DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 is set to zero. If DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 is zero, the DHCP 66 client is on the same subnet as the DHCP 66 server, and the DHCP 66 server sends any return messages to either the DHCP 66 client's network address, if that address was supplied in DHCP 66 ciaddr-field 124 (FIG. 6), or to a client's hardware address specified in DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 (FIG. 6) or to a local subnet broadcast address (e.g., 255.255.255.255). At step 144, a DHCP 66 layer on TRAC 24 broadcasts the DHCPDISCOVER message on its local network leaving DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 intact since it already contains a non-zero value. TRAC's 24 local network includes connections to one or more DHCP 66 proxies (i.e., network host interface proxies). The DHCP 66 proxies accept DHCP 66 messages originally from CM 16 destined for DHCP 66 servers connected to network host interfaces available on CMTS 12 since TRAC 24 has no direct access to DCHP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces available on CMTS 12. DHCP 66 proxies are not used in a typical DHCP 66 discovery process. One or more DHCP 66 proxies on TRAC's 24 local network recognizes the DHCPDISCOVER message and forwards it to one or more DHCP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interfaces) available on CMTS 12 at step 146. Since DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 (FIG. 6) in the DHCPDISCOVER message sent by CM 16 is already non-zero (i.e., contains the downstream IP address of CMTS 12), the DHCP 66 proxies also leave DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 intact. One or more DHCP 66 servers for network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interfaces) available on CMTS 12 receive the DHCPDISCOVER message and generate a DHCP 66 offer message ("DHCPOFFER") at step 148. The DHCP 66 offer message is an offer of configuration parameters sent from network host interfaces to DHCP 66 servers and back to a network host client (e.g., CM 16) in response to a DHCPDISCOVER message. The DHCP 66 offer message is sent with the message fields set as illustrated in Table 7. However, other field settings can also be used. DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 (e.g., second message field from step 102 of method 92) contains an IP 54 address for a network host interface available on CMTS 12 and used for receiving data packets from data network 28.
TABLE 7
DHCP 66 Parameter Description
FLAGS 122 BROADCAST bit set to zero.
YIADDR 126 IP 54 address from a network
host interface to allow CM 16 to
receive data from data network
28 via a network host interface
available on CMTS 12.
SIADDR 128 An IP 54 address for a TFTP 64
server to download configuration
information for an interface host.
CHADDR 132 MAC 44 address of CM 16.
SNAME 134 Optional DHCP 66 server
identifier with an interface host.
FILE 136 A TFTP 64 configuration file
name for CM 16.
DHCP 66 servers send the DHCPOFFER message to the address specified in 66 giaddr-field 130 (i.e., CMTS 12) from the DHCPDISCOVER message if associated network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interfaces) can offer the requested service (e.g., IP 54 service) to CM 16. The DHCPDISCOVER message DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 contains a downstream channel IP address 80 of CMTS 12 that was received by CM 16 in TSI message 76. This allows CMTS 12 to receive the DHCPOFFER messages from the DHCP 66 servers and send them to CM 16 via a downstream channel on cable network 14. At step 150 in FIG. 7B, CMTS 12 receives one or more DHCPOFFER messages from one or more DHCP 66 servers associated with the network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interfaces). CMTS 12 examines DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 in the DHCPOFFER messages and sends the DHCPOFFER messages to CM 16 via cable network 14. DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 contains an IP 54 address for a network host IP 54 interface available on CMTS 12 and used for receiving IP 54 data packets from data network 28. DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 contains the MAC 44 layer address for CM 16 on a downstream cable channel from CMTS 12 via cable network 14. CMTS 12 knows the location of CM 16 since it sent CM 16 a MAC 44 layer address in one or more initialization messages (e.g., TSI message 76). If a BROADCAST bit in flags field 124 is set to one, CMTS 12 sends the DHCPOFFER messages to a broadcast IP 54 address (e.g., 255.255.255.255) instead of the address specified in DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126. DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 is still used to determine that MAC 44 layer address. If the BROADCAST bit in DHCP 66 flags field 122 is set, CMTS 12 does not update internal address or routing tables based upon DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 pair when a broadcast message is sent. At step 152, CM 16 receives one or more DHCPOFFER messages from CMTS 12 via cable network 14 on a downstream connection. At step 154, CM 16 selects an offer for IP 54 service from one of the network host interfaces (e.g., an IP interfaces 54) available on CMTS 12 that responded to the DHCPDISOVER message sent at step 142 in FIG. 7A and establishes a virtual IP 54 connection. The selected DHCPOFFER message contains a network host interface address (e.g., IP 54 address) in DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 (FIG. 6). A cable modem acknowledges the selected network host interface with DHCP 66 message sequence explained below. After selecting and acknowledging a network host interface, CM 16 has discovered an IP 54 interface address available on CMTS 12 for completing a virtual IP 54 connection with data network 28. Acknowledging a network host interface is explained below. The virtual IP 54 connection allows IP 54 data from data network 28 to be sent to CMTS 12 which forwards the IP 54 packets to CM 16 on a downstream channel via cable network 14. CM 16 sends response IP 54 packets back to data network 28 via PSTN 22 and TRAC 24. FIG. 8 is a block diagram illustrating a data-over-cable system 156 for the method illustrated in FIGS. 7A and 7B. Data-over-cable system 156 includes DHCP 66 proxies 158, DHCP 66 servers 160 and associated Network Host Interfaces 162 available on CMTS 12. Multiple DHCP 66 proxies 158, DHCP 66 servers 160 and network host interfaces 162 are illustrated as single boxes in FIG. 8. FIG. 8 also illustrates DHCP 66 proxies 158 separate from TRAC 24. In one embodiment of the present invention, TRAC 24 includes DHCP 66 proxy functionality and no separate DHCP 66 proxies 158 are used. In such an embodiment, TRAC 24 forwards DHCP 66 messages using DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 to DHCP 66 servers 160 available on CMTS 12. FIG. 9 is a block diagram illustrating a message flow 162 of method 140 (FIGS. 7A and 7B). Message flow 162 includes DHCP proxies 158 and DHCP servers 160 illustrated in FIG. 8 Steps 142, 144, 146, 148, 150 and 154 of method 140 (FIGS. 7A and 7B) are illustrated in FIG. 9. In one embodiment of the present invention, DHCP proxies 158 are not separate entities, but are included in TRAC 24. In such an embodiment, DHCP proxy services are provided directly by TRAC 24. Resolving Addresses For Network Host Interfaces Since CM 16 receives multiple DHCPOFFER messages (Step 152FIG. 7B) CM 16 resolves and acknowledges one offer from a selected network host interface. FIGS. 10A and 10B are a flow diagram illustrating a method 166 for resolving and acknowledging host addresses in a data-over-cable system. Method 166 includes a first network device that is connected to a first network with a downstream connection of a first connection type, and connected to a second network with an upstream connection of a second connection type. The first and second networks are connected to a third network with a third connection type. In one embodiment of the present invention, the first network device is CM 16, the first network is cable network 14, the second network is PSTN 22 and the third network is data network 28 (e.g., the Internet). The downstream connection is a cable television connection, the upstream connection is a telephony connection, and the third connection is an IP connection. Turning to FIG. 10A, one or more first messages are received on the first network device from the first network on the downstream connection at step 168. The one or more first messages are offers from one or more network host interfaces available on the first network to provide the first network device a connection to the third network. The first network device selects one of the network host interfaces using message fields in one of the one or more first messages at step 170. The first network device creates a second message with a second message type to accept the offered services from a selected network host interface at step 172. The second message includes a connection address for the first network in a first message field and an identifier to identify the selected network host interface in a second message field. The first network device sends the second message over the upstream connection to the second network at step 174. The second network uses the first message field in the second message to forward the second message to the one or more network host interfaces available on first network at step 176. A network host interface available on the first network identified in second message field in the second message from the first network device recognizes an identifier for the network host interface at 178 in FIG. 10B. The selected network host interface sends a third message with a third message type to the first network at step 180. The third message is an acknowledgment for the first network device that the selected network host interface received the second message from the first network device. The first network stores a connection address for the selected network interface in one or more tables on the first network at step 182. The first network will forward data from the third network to the first network device when it is received on the selected network host interface using the connection address in the one or more routing tables. The first network forwards the third message to the first network device on the downstream connection at step 184. The first network device receives the third message at step 186. The first network and the first network device have the necessary addresses for a virtual connection that allows data to be sent from the third network to a network host interface on the first network, and from the first network over the downstream connection to the first network device. Method 166 accomplishes resolving network interface hosts addresses from a cable modem in a data-over-cable with telephony return. Method 166 of the present invention is used in data-over-cable system 10 with telephony return. However, the present invention is not limited to data-over-cable system 10 with telephony return and can be used in data-over-cable system 10 without telephony return by using an upstream cable channel instead of an upstream telephony channel. FIGS. 11A and 11B are a flow diagram illustrating a method 188 for resolving discovered host addresses in data-over-cable system 10 with telephony return. At step 190 in FIG. 11A, CM 16 receives one or more DHCPOFFER messages from one or more DHCP 66 servers associated with one or more network host interfaces (e.g., at step 168 in method 166). The one or more DHCPOFFER messages include DHCP 66 fields set as illustrated in Table 7 above. However, other field settings could also be used. At step 192, CM 16 selects one of the DHCPOFFER messages (see also, step 170 in method 166). At step 194, CM 16 creates a DHCP 66 request message ("DHCPREQUEST") message to request the services offered by a network host interface selected at step 192. The fields of the DHCP request message are set as illustrated in Table 8. However, other field settings may also be used.
TABLE 8
DHCP 66
Parameter Description
OP 110 Set to BOOTREQUEST.
HTYPE 112 Set to network type (e.g., one for 10 Mbps
Ethernet).
HLEN 114 Set to network Iength (e.g., six for 10 Mbps
Ethernet)
HOPS 116 Set to zero.
FLAGS 118 Set BROADCAST bit to zero.
CIADDR 124 If CM 16 has previously been assigned an IP
address, the IP address is placed in this field.
If CM 16 has previously been assigned an IP
address by DHCP 66, and also has been
assigned an address via IPCP, CM 16 places
the DHCP 66 IP 54 address in this field.
YIADDR 126 IP 54 address sent from the selected network
interface host in DCHPOFFER message
GIADDR 130 CM 16 places the Downstream Channel IP 54
address 80 CMTS 12 obtained in TSI
message 76 on a cable downstream channel
in this field.
CHADDR 132 CM 16 places its 48-bit MAC 44 LAN address
in this field.
SNAME 134 DHCP 66 server identifier for the selected
network interface host
The DHCPREQUEST message is used to "request" services from the selected IP 54 host interface available on CMTS 12 using a DHCP 66 server associated with the selected network host interface. DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 (FIG. 6) includes the downstream channel IP address 80 for CMTS 12 obtained in TSI message 76 (e.g., the first message-field from step 172 of method 166). Putting the downstream channel IP address 80 obtained in TSI message 76 allows the DHCPREQUEST message to be forwarded by TRAC 24 to DCHP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces available on CMTS 12. DHCP 66 giaddr-field 126 contains an identifier (second message field, step 172 in method 166) DHCP 66 sname-field 134 contains a DHCP 66 server identifier associated with the selected network host interface. If DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 in a DHCP message from a DHCP 66 client is non-zero, a DHCP 66 server sends any return messages to a DHCP 66 server port on a DHCP 66 relaying agent (e.g., CMTS 12) whose address appears in DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130. If DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 is zero, the DHCP 66 client is on the same subnet as the DHCP 66 server, and the DHCP 66 server sends any return messages to either the DHCP 66 client's network address, if that address was supplied in DHCP 66 ciaddr-field 124, or to the client's hardware address specified in DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 or to the local subnet broadcast address. Returning to FIG. 11A at step 196, CM 16 sends the DHCPREQUEST message on the upstream connection to TRAC 24 via PSTN 22. At step 198, a DHCP 66 layer on TRAC 24 broadcasts the DHCPREQUEST message on its local network leaving DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 intact since it already contains a non-zero value. TRAC's 24 local network includes connections to one or more DHCP 66 proxies. The DHCP 66 proxies accept DHCP 66 messages originally from CM 16 destined for DHCP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces available on CMTS 12. In another embodiment of the present invention, TRAC 24 provides the DHCP 66 proxy functionality, and no separate DHCP 66 proxies are used. The one or more DHCP 66 proxies on TRAC's 24 local network message forwards the DHCPOFFER to one or more of the DHCP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interfaces) available on CMTS 12 at step 200 in FIG. 11B. Since DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 in the DHCPDISCOVER message sent by CM 16 is already non-zero (i.e., contains the downstream IP address of CMTS 12), the DHCP 66 proxies leave DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 intact. One or more DHCP 66 servers for the selected network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interface) available on CMTS 12 receives the DHCPOFFER message at step 202. A selected DHCP 66 server recognizes a DHCP 66 server identifier in DHCP 66 sname-field 134 or the IP 54 address that was sent in the DCHPOFFER message in the DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 from the DHCPREQUST message as being for the selected DHCP 66 server. The selected DHCP 66 server associated with network host interface selected by CM 16 in the DHCPREQUEST message creates and sends a DCHP 66 acknowledgment message ("DHCPACK") to CMTS 12 at step 204. The DHCPACK message is sent with the message fields set as illustrated in Table 9. However, other field settings can also be used. DHCP 66 yiaddr-field again contains the IP 54 address for the selected network host interface available on CMTS 12 for receiving data packets from data network 28.
TABLE 9
DHCP 66 Parameter Description
FLAGS 122 Set a BROADCAST bit to zero.
YIADDR 126 IP 54 address for the selected
network host interface to allow
CM 16 to receive data from data
network 28.
SIADDR 128 An IP 54 address for a TFTP 64
server to download configuration
information for an interface host.
CHADDR 132 MAC 44 address of CM 16.
SNAME 134 DHCP 66 server identifier
associated with the selected
network host interface.
FILE 136 A configuration file name for an
network interface host.
The selected DHCP 66 server sends the DHCACK message to the address specified in DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 from the DHCPREQUEST message to CM 16 to verify the selected network host interface (e.g., IP 54 interface) will offer the requested service (e.g., IP 54 service). At step 206, CMTS 12 receives the DHCPACK message from the selected DHCP 66 server associated with the selected network host interface IP 54 address(e.g., IP 54 interface). CMTS 12 examines DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 in the DHCPOFFER messages. DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 contains an IP 54 address for a network host IP 54 interface available on CMTS 12 and used for receiving IP 54 data packets from data network 28 for CM 16. DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 contains the MAC 44 layer address for CM 16 on a downstream cable channel from CMTS 12 via cable network 14. CMTS 12 updates an Address Resolution Protocol ("ARP") table and other routing tables on CMTS 12 to reflect the addresses in DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 at step 208. As is known in the art, ARP allows a gateway such as CMTS 12 to forward any datagrams from a data network such as data network 28 it receives for hosts such as CM 16. ARP is defined in RFC-826, incorporated herein by reference. CMTS 12 stores a pair of network address values in the ARP table, the IP 54 address of the selected network host interface from DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and a Network Point of Attachment ("NPA") address. In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, The NPA address is a MAC 44 layer address for CM 16 via a downstream cable channel. The IP/NPA address pair are stored in local routing tables with the IP/NPA addresses of hosts (e.g., CMs 16) that are attached to cable network 14. At step 210, CMTS 12 sends the DHCPACK message to CM 16 via cable network 14. At step 212, CM 16 receives the DHCPACK message, and along with CMTS 12 has addresses for a virtual connection between data network 28 and CM 16. When data packets arrive on the IP 54 address for the selected host interface they are sent to CMTS 12 and CMTS 12 forwards them using a NPA (i.e., MAC 44 address) from the routing tables on a downstream channel via cable network 14 to CM 16. If a BROADCAST bit in flags field 124 is set to one in the DHCPACK, CMTS 12 sends the DHCPACK messages to a broadcast IP 54 address (e.g., 255.255.255.255). DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 is still used to determine that MAC layer address. If the BROADCAST bit in flags field 122 is set, CMTS 12 does not update the ARP table or offer routing tables based upon DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 pair when a broadcast message is sent. FIG. 12 is a block diagram illustrating the message flow 214 of the method 188 illustrated in FIGS. 11A and 11B. Message flow 214 includes DHCP proxies 158 and DHCP servers 160 illustrated in FIG. 8. Method steps 194, 196, 198, 204, 208, 210 and 212 of method 188 (FIGS. 11A and 11B) are illustrated in FIG. 12. In one embodiment of the present invention, DHCP proxies 158 are not separate entities, but are included in TRAC 24. In such an embodiment, DHCP proxy services are provided directly by TRAC 24. After method 188, CMTS 12 has a valid IP/MAC address pair in one or more address routing tables including an ARP table to forward IP 54 data packets from data network 28 to CM 16, thereby creating a virtual IP 54 data path to/from CM 16 as was illustrated in method 92 (FIG. 5) and Table 3. CM 16 has necessary parameters to proceed to the next phase of initialization, a download of a configuration file via TFTP 64. Once CM 16 has received the configuration file and has been initialized, it registers with CMTS 12 and is ready to receive data from data network 14. In the event that CM 16 is not compatible with the configuration of the network host interface received in the DHCPACK message, CM 16 may generate a DHCP 66 decline message ("DHCPDECLINE") and transmit it to TRAC 24 via PSTN 22. A DHCP 66 layer in TRAC 24 forwards the DHCPDECLINE message to CMTS 12. Upon seeing a DHCPDECLINE message, CMTS 12 flushes its ARP tables and routing tables to remove the now invalid IP/MAC pairing. If an IP 54 address for a network host interface is returned that is different from the IP 54 address sent by CM 16 in the DCHCPREQUEST message, CM 16 uses the IP 54 address it receives in the DHCPACK message as the IP 54 address of the selected network host interface for receiving data from data network 28. The present invention is described with respect to, but is not limited to a data-over-cable-system with telephony return. Method 188 can also be used with a cable modem that has a two-way connection (i.e., upstream and downstream) to cable network 14 and CMTS 12. In a data-over-cable-system without telephony return, CM 16 would broadcast the DHCPREQUEST message to one or more DHCP 66 servers associated with one or more network host interfaces available on CMTS 12 using an upstream connection on data network 14 including the IP 54 address of CMTS 12 in DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130. Method 188 accomplishes resolving addresses for network interface hosts from a cable modem in a data-over-cable with or without telephony return, and without extensions to the existing DHCP protocol. CPE Initialization In A Data-Over-Cable System CPE 18 also uses DHCP 66 to generate requests to obtain IP 54 addresses to allow CPE 18 to also receive data from data network 28 via CM 16. In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, CM 16 functions as a standard BOOTP relay agent/DHCP Proxy 158 to facilitate CPE's 18 access to DHCP 66 server 160. FIGS. 13A and 13B are a flow diagram illustrating a method 216 for obtaining addresses for customer premise equipment. CM 16 and CMTS 12 use information from method 214 to construct IP 54 routing and ARP table entries for network host interfaces 162 providing data to CMCI 20 and to CPE 18. Method 216 in FIGS. 13A and 13B includes a data-over-cable system with telephony return and first network device with a second network device for connecting the first network device to a first network with a downstream connection of a first connection type, and for connecting to a second network with an upstream connection of a second connection type. The first and second networks are connected to a third network with a third connection type. In one embodiment of the present invention, data-over-cable system with telephony return is data-over-cable system 10 with the first network device CPE 18 and the second network device CM 16. The first network is cable television network 14, the downstream connection is a cable television connection, the second network is PSTN 22, the upstream connection is a telephony connection, the third network is data network 28 (e.g., the Internet or an intranet) and the third type of connection is an IP 54 connection. However, the present invention is not limited to the network components described and other network components may also be used. Method 216 allows CPE 18 to determine an IP 54 network host interface address available on CMTS 12 to receive IP 54 data packets from data network 54, thereby establishing a virtual IP 54 connection with data network 28 via CM 16. Returning to FIG. 13A at step 218, a first message of a first type (e.g., a DHCP 66 discover message) with a first message field for a first connection is created on the first network device. The first message is used to discover a network host interface address on the first network to allow a virtual connection to the third network. At step 220, the first network device sends the first message to the second network device. The second network device checks the first message field at step 222. If the first message field is zero, the second network device puts its own connection address into the first message field at step 224. The second network device connection address allows the messages from network host interfaces on the first network to return messages to the second network device attached to the first network device. If the first message field is non-zero, the second network device does not alter the first message field since there could be a relay agent attached to the first network device that may set the first connection address field. At step 226, the second network device forwards the first message to a connection address over the upstream connection to the second network. In one embodiment of the present invention, the connection address is an IP broadcast address (e.g., 255.255.255.255). However, other connection addresses can also be used. The second network uses the first connection address in the first message field in the first message to forward the first message to one or more network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 network host interfaces) available on first network at step 228. One or more network host interfaces available on the first network that can provide the services requested in first message send a second message with a second message type with a second connection address in a second message field to the first network at step 230 in FIG. 13B. The second connection address allows the first network device to receive data packets from the third network via a network host interface on the first network. The first network forwards the one or more second messages on the downstream connection to the second network device at step 232. The second network device forwards the one or more second messages to the first network device at step 234. The first network device selects one of the one or more network host interfaces on the first network using the one or more second messages at step 236. This allows a virtual connection to be established between the third network and the first network device via the selected network host interface on the first network and the second network device. FIGS. 14A and 14B are a flow diagram illustrating a method 240 for resolving addresses for the network host interface selected by a first network device to create a virtual connection to the third network. Turning to FIG. 14A, at step 240 one or more second messages are received with a second message type on the first network device from the second network device from the first network on a downstream connection at step 242. The one or more second messages are offers from one or more protocol servers associated with one or more network host interfaces available on the first network to provide the first network device a connection to the third network. The first network device selects one of the network host interfaces using one of the one or more second messages at step 244. The first network device creates a third message with a third message type to accept the offered services from the selected network host interface at step 246. The third message includes a connection address for the first network in a first message field and an identifier to identify the selected network host interface in a second message field. At step 248, first network device equipment sends the third message to the second network device. The second network device sends the third message over the upstream connection to the second network at step 250. The second network uses the first message field in the third message to forward the third message to the one or more network host interfaces available on first network at step 252. A network host interface available on the first network identified in second message field in the third message from the first network device recognizes an identifier for the selected network host interface at step 254 in FIG. 14B. The selected network host interface sends a fourth message with a fourth message type to the first network at step 256. The fourth message is an acknowledgment for the first network device that the selected network host interface received the third message. The fourth message includes a second connection address in a third message field. The second connection address is a connection address for the selected network host interface. The first network stores the connection address for the selected network interface from the third message in one or more routing tables (e.g., an ARP table) on the first network at step 258. The first network will forward data from the third network to the first network device via the second network device when it is received on the selected network host interface using the connection address from the third message field. The first network forwards the fourth message to the second network device on the downstream connection at step 260. The second network device receives the fourth message and stores the connection address from the third message field for the selected network interface in one or more routing tables on the second network device at step 262. The connection address for the selected network interface allows the second network device to forward data from the third network sent by the selected network interface to the customer premise equipment. At step 264, the second network device forward the fourth message to the first network device. At step 266, the first network device establishes a virtual connection between the third network and the first network device. After step 266, the first network, the second network device and the first network device have the necessary connection addresses for a virtual connection that allows data to be sent from the third network to a network host interface on the first network, and from the first network over the downstream connection to the second network and then to the first network device. In one embodiment of the present invention, method 240 accomplishes resolving network interface hosts addresses from customer premise equipment with a cable modem in a data-over-cable with telephony return without extensions to the existing DHCP protocol. Methods 216 and 240 of the present invention are used in data-over-cable system 10 with telephony return with CM 16 and CPE 18. However, the present invention is not limited to data-over-cable system 10 with telephony return and can be used in data-over-cable system 10 without telephony return by using an upstream cable channel instead of an upstream telephony channel. FIGS. 15A and 15B are a flow diagram illustrating a method 268 for addressing network host interfaces from CPE 18. At step 270 in FIG. 15A, CPE 18 generates a DHCPDISCOVER message broadcasts the DHCPDISCOVER message on its local network with the fields set as illustrated in Table 6 above with addresses for CPE 18 instead of CM 16. However, more or fewer field could also be set. CM 16 receives the DHCPDISCOVER as a standard BOOTP relay agent at step 272. The DHCP DISCOVER message has a MAC 44 layer address for CPE 18 in DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132, which CM 16 stores in one or more routing tables. As a BOOTP relay agent, the CM 16 checks the DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 (FIG. 6) at step 274. If DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 is set to zero, CM 16 put its IP 54 address into DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 at step 276. If DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 is non-zero, CM 16 does not alter DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 since there could be another BOOTP relay agent attached to CPE 18 which may have already set DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130. Any BOOTP relay agent attached to CPE 18 would have also have acquired its IP 54 address from using a DCHP 66 discovery process (e.g., FIG. 12). Returning to FIG. 15A, at step 278, CM 16 broadcasts the DHCPDISCOVER message to a broadcast address via PSTN 22 to TRAC 24. In one embodiment of the present invention, the broadcast address is an IP 54 broadcast address (e.g., 255.255.255.255). At step 280, one or more DHCP 66 proxies 158 associated with TRAC 24, recognize the DHCPDISOVER message, and forward it to one or more DHCP 66 servers 160 associated with one or more network host interfaces 162 available on CMTS 12. Since DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 is already non-zero, the DHCP proxies leave DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 intact. In another embodiment of the present invention, TRAC 24 includes DCHP 66 proxy 158 functionality and no separate DHCP 66 proxies 158 are used. At step 282 in FIG. 15B, the one or more DHCP servers 160 receive the DHCPDISCOVER message from one or more DHCP proxies, and generate one or more DHCPOFFER messages to offer connection services for one or more network host interfaces 162 available on CMTS 12 with the fields set as illustrated in Table 7. The one or more DHCP servers 160 send the one or more DHCPOFFER messages to the address specified in DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 (e.g., CM 16 or a BOOTP relay agent on CPE 18), which is an IP 54 address already contained in an ARP or other routing table in CMTS 12. Since CMTS 12 also functions as a relay agent for the one or more DHCP servers 160, the one or more DHCPOFFER messages are received on CMTS 12 at step 284. CMTS 12 examines DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 in the DHCPOFFER messages, and sends the DHCPOFFER messages down cable network 14 to IP 54 address specified in the giaddr-field 130. The MAC 44 address for CM 16 is obtained through a look-up of the hardware address associated with DHCP 66 chaddr-field 130. If the BROADCAST bit in DHCP 66 flags-field 122 is set to one, CMTS 12 sends the DHCPOFFER message to a broadcast IP 54 address (e.g., 255.255.255.255), instead of the address specified in DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126. CMTS 12 does not update its ARP or other routing tables based upon the broadcast DCHP 66 yiaddr-field 126 DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 address pair. Returning to FIG. 15B, CM 16 receives the one or more DHCPOFFER messages and forwards them to CPE 18 at step 286. CM 16 uses the MAC 44 address specified determined by DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 look-up in its routing tables to find the address of CPE 18 even if the BROADCAST bit in DHCP 66 flags-field 122 is set. At step 290, CPE 18 receives the one or more DHCPOFFER messages from CM 16. At step 292, CPE 18 selects one of the DHCPOFFER messages to allow a virtual connection to be established between data network 28 and CPE 18. Method 266 accomplishes addressing network interface hosts from CPE 18 in data-over-cable system 10 without extensions to the existing DHCP protocol. FIGS. 16A and 16B are a flow diagram illustrating a method 294 for resolving network host interfaces from CPE 18. At step 296, CPE 18 receives the one or more DHCPOFFER messages from one or more DHCP 66 servers associated with one or more network host interface available on CMTS 12. At step 298, CPE 18 chooses one offer of services from a selected network host interface. At step 300, CPE 18 generates a DHCPREQUEST message with the fields set as illustrated in Table 8 above with addresses for CPE 18 instead of CM 16. However, more or fewer fields could also be set. At step 302, CPE 18 sends the DHCPREQUEST message to CM 16. At step 304, CM 16 forwards the message to TRAC 24 via PSTN 22. At step 306, a DHCP 66 layer on TRAC 24 broadcasts the DHCPREQUEST message on its local network leaving DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 intact since it already contains a non-zero value. TRAC's 24 local network includes connections to one or more DHCP 66 proxies. The DHCP 66 proxies accept DHCP 66 messages originally from CPE 18 destined for DHCP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces available on CMTS 12. In another embodiment of the present invention, TRAC 24 provides the DHCP 66 proxy functionality, and no separate DHCP 66 proxies are used. One or more DHCP 66 proxies on TRAC's 24 local network recognize the DHCPOFFER message and forward it to one or more of the DHCP 66 servers associated with network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interfaces) available on CMTS 12 at step 308 in FIG. 16B. Since DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 in the DHCPDISCOVER message sent by CPE 18 is already non-zero, the DHCP 66 proxies leave DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 intact. One or more DHCP 66 servers for the selected network host interfaces (e.g., IP 54 interface) available on CMTS 12 receive the DHCPOFFER message at step 310. A selected DHCP 66 server recognizes a DHCP 66 server identifier in DHCP 66 sname-field 134 or the IP 54 address that was sent in the DCHPOFFER message in the DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 from the DHCPREQUST message for the selected DHCP 66 server. The selected DHCP 66 server associated with network host interface selected by CPE 18 in the DHCPREQUEST message creates and sends a DCHP acknowledgment message ("DHCPACK") to CMTS 12 at step 312 using the DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130. The DHCPACK message is sent with the message fields set as illustrated in Table 9. However, other field settings can also be used. DHCP 66 yiaddr-field contains the IP 54 address for the selected network host interface available on CMTS 12 for receiving data packets from data network 28 for CPE 18. At step 314, CMTS 12 receives the DHCPACK message. CMTS 12 examines the DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 and looks up that IP address in its ARP table for an associated MAC 44 address. This is a MAC 44 address for CM 16, which sent the DHCPREQUEST message from CPE 18. CMTS 12 uses the MAC 44 address associated with the DHCP 66 giaddr-field 130 and the DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 to update its routing and ARP tables reflecting this address pairing at step 316. At step 318, CMTS 12 sends the DHCPACK message on a downstream channel on cable network 14 to the IP 54 and MAC 44 addresses, respectively (i.e., to CM 16). If the BROADCAST bit in the DHCP 66 flags-field 122 is set to one, CMTS 12 sends the DHCPACK message to a broadcast IP 54 address (e.g., 255.255.255.255), instead of the address specified in the DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126. CMTS 12 uses the MAC 44 address associated with the DHCP 66 chaddr-field 130 even if the BROADCAST bit is set. CM 16 receives the DHCPACK message. It examines the DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and chaddr-field 132, and updates its routing table and an ARP routing table to reflect the address pairing at step 320. At step 322, CM 16 sends the DHCPACK message to CPE 18 via CMCI 20 at IP 54 and MAC 44 addresses respectively from its routing tables. If the BROADCAST bit in the DHCP 66 flags-field 122 is set to one, CM 16 sends the downstream packet to a broadcast IP 54 address (e.g., 255.255.255.255), instead of the address specified in DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126. CM 16 uses the MAC 44 address specified in DHCP 66 chaddr-field 132 even if the BROADCAST bit is set to located CPE 18. At step 324, CPE 18 receives the DHCPACK from CM 16 and has established a virtual connection to data network 28. In the event that CPE 18 is not compatible with the configuration received in the DHCPACK message, CPE 18 may generate a DHCP 66 decline ("DHCPDECLINE") message and send it to CM 16. CM 16 will transmit the DHCPDECLINE message up the PPP 50 link via PSTN 22 to TRAC 24. On seeing a DHCPDECLINE message TRAC 24 sends a unicast copy of the message to CMTS 12. CM 16 and CMTS 12 examine the DHCP 66 yiaddr-field 126 and giaddr-field 130, and update their routing and ARP tables to flush any invalid pairings. Upon completion of methods 266 and 292, CM 16 CMTS 12 have valid IP/MAC address pairings in their routing and ARP tables. These tables store the same set of IP 54 addresses, but does not associate them with the same MAC 44 addresses. This is because CMTS 12 resolves all CPE 18 IP 54 addresses to the MAC 44 address of a corresponding CM 16. The CMs 16, on other hand, are able to address the respective MAC 44 addresses of their CPEs 18. This also allows DHCP 66 clients associated with CPE 18 to function normally since the addressing that is done in CM 16 and CMTS 12 is transparent to CPE 18 hosts. FIG. 17 is a block diagram illustrating a message flow 326 for methods 268 and 294 in FIGS. 15A, 15B, and 16A and 16B. Message flow 326 illustrates a message flow for methods 268 and 294, for a data-over-cable system with and without telephony return. In another embodiment of the present invention, CM 16 forwards requests from CPE 18 via an upstream connection on cable network 14 to DHCP servers 160 associated with one or more network host interfaces available on CMTS 12. Method 268 and 294 accomplishes resolving addresses for network interface hosts from customer premise equipment in a data-over-cable with or without telephony return without extensions to the existing DHCP protocol. Methods 268 and 294 of the present invention are used in data-over-cable system 10 with telephony return. However, the present invention is not limited to data-over-cable system 10 with telephony return and can be used in data-over-cable system 10 without telephony return by using an upstream cable channel instead of an upstream telephony channel. Secure Cable Modem Registration FIG. 18 is a block diagram illustrating a data-over-cable system 330 used for an illustrative embodiment of the present invention. Data-over-cable system 330 is similar to the data-over-cable system illustrated in FIG. 8. However, FIG. 18 illustrates TFTP 64 server 332 used to obtain configuration information 334 in a configuration file for CM 16. The configuration file includes MIC fields and is subject to the similar attacks by rouge users as those described for the cable modem registration message above. A secure protocol server, such as a secure TFTP server, is used to send a configuration file with a unique identifier, a selected time-value and a message integrity check value using methods similar to those described for an illustrative embodiment of the present invention. Secure transfer of a configuration file from a secure protocol server to a cable modem is described in co-pending application Ser. No. 09/018,756 assigned to the same assignee as the present application. Configuration information for an exemplary configuration file is illustrated in Type/Length/Value ("TLV") format in Table 10. However, more or fewer configuration parameters could also be used. In addition, only a description of the Value in the TLV format is included since the numbers used for the Value fields are implementation specific.
TABLE 10
Type Length Description of Value
1 4 Receive frequency
2 1 Upstream channel identifier
4x N Class of service header
41 1 Class identifier
42 4 Maximum downstream data
rate in bits/sec
43 4 Maximum upstream data rate
in bits/sec
44 1 Upstream channel priority
45 4 Upstream guaranteed
minimum data rate in bits/sec
46 2 Maximum upstream
configuration setting in
minislots
47 1 Privacy enable
8 3 Vendor Identifier configuration
setting
17x N Baseline privacy settings
header
171 4 Authorize timeout seconds
172 4 Reauthorize wait timeout
seconds
173 4 Authorization wait timeout
seconds
174 4 Operational wait timeout
seconds
175 4 Re-key wait timeout seconds
176 4 TEK grace time seconds
9 N Software upgrade filename
10 1 SNMP access control
11 N Arbitrary SNMP object setting
0 N Padding for 4-byte boundary
3 1 Network access
6 16 CM-MIC
7 16 CMTS-MIC
255 N/A End-of-file
FIG. 19 is a flow diagram illustrating a method 336 for secure registration for a network device. Method 336 includes receiving a first configuration file with configuration information on a first network device from a first protocol server at step 338. The first configuration file includes configuration information with multiple configuration parameters. A first message is created on the first network device including one or more configuration parameters from the first configuration file at step 340. A unique identifier (e.g., a network address) for the first network device is added to the first message at step 342. The unique identifier may be obtained by the first network device from a second protocol server in a second message during an initialization sequence. A selected time-value (e.g., a "time-now" value) is added to the first message at step 344. The selected time-value indicates an approximate sending time of the first message. A message integrity check value is calculated at step 346 using the unique identifier, selected time-value and one or more configuration parameters from the configuration information in a pre-determined order to uniquely identify the configuration parameters for the network device. The message integrity check value is calculated using a pre-determined cryptographic technique. The message integrity check value is added to the first message at step 348. The first message is sent from the first network device to a second network device at step 350. The second network device uses the message integrity check value including the unique identifier and selected time-value to uniquely identify the first network device and prevent another network device from using the configuration information in the first message at a later time. In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, the first network device is CM 16, the first message is a cable modem registration request message, the unique identifier is an IP 54 address for CM 16, the second network device is CMTS 12, the first protocol server is TFTP server 332 and the second protocol server is DHCP server 160. However, the present invention is not limited to the illustrative embodiment and other network devices, protocol servers and messages in data-over-cable system 330 could also be used for secure registration of a network device. FIG. 20 is a flow diagram illustrating a method 352 for secure registration for a cable modem. Method 352 includes receiving a first configuration file on CM 16 from TFTP server 332 at step 354. The first configuration file includes multiple configuration parameters (e.g., from Table 10). A cable modem registration request message is created on CM 16 including configuration information from the first configuration file at step 356. A format for an illustrative registration request message is shown in FIG. 22 and described below. The registration request message allows CM 16 to register its presence with CMTS 12 and receive data from cable network 14 and data network 28 via CMTS 12. A unique identifier for CM 16 is added to the first message at step 358. In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, the network address is an IP 54 address that CM 16 received during the DHCP 66 initialization sequence (FIG. 12). However, other network addresses could also be used (e.g., a MAC 44 address). In addition, the unique identifier (e.g., a domain name cm1 data-over-cable net) could also be obtained from other sources (e.g., CMTS 12, or TRAC 24). Table 11 illustrates a unique identifier added to the registration request message in TLV format. However, other unique identifier layout could also be used.
TABLE 11
Type Length Descrition of Value
Y 4 Unique identifer, e.g., P54
address of CM 16
A selected time-value is added to the registration request message at step 360. The selected time-value is called a "time-now" value and indicates an approximate sending time of the registration request message from CM 16 to CMTS 12. Table 12 illustrates a selected time value in TLV format. However, other time value layouts could also be used.
TABLE 12
Type Length Description of Value
Z 4 Number of seconds since
00:00 on January 1, 1970.
(UNIX Epoch Time, RFC-868)
The selected time value is used as defined in RFC-868; incorporated herein by reference. However, the selected time-value is the number of seconds since time 00:00 on Jan. 1, 1970 (i.e., UNIX epoch time) instead of the number of seconds since time 00:00 on Jan. 1, 1900. However, other time values and formats could also be used (e.g., seconds since boot time, or a common network clock time). In one embodiment of the present invention, CM 16 uses configuration parameters from the configuration file received from TFTP server 332 as well as additional configuration parameters such as the IP 54 address (Table 11) and selected-time value (Table 12). In another embodiment of the present invention, CM 16 uses less than all of the configuration parameters from the configuration file received from TFTP server 332 as well as additional configuration parameters such as the IP 54 address (Table 11) and selected-time value (Table 12). When additional configuration parameters are added to the registration request message (e.g., the unique identifier and selected time-value), an additional field is used in the registration request message is used to indicate the addition of configuration parameters to the registration request message. Table 13 illustrates a message type TLV with additional configuration parameters.
TABLE 13
Type Length Description of Value
T 1 Registration request message
version
Table 14 illustrates values for the registration request value message.
TABLE 14
Registration request
message values Definition of value
0 Default, no additional configuration parameters
added.
1 Additional configuration parameters added.
Returning to FIG. 20, a Message Integrity Check ("MIC") value is calculated using the unique identifier (Table 11), the selected time-value (Table 12) and one or more configuration parameters from the configuration information (Table 10) in a pre-determined order to uniquely identify the configuration information for CM 16 at step 362. The MIC value is calculated using a using a pre-determined cryptographic technique. In one embodiment of the present invention, authentication of the configuration information in the registration request message is provided by two Message Integrity Check ("MIC") fields, "CM-MIC" and "CMTS-MIC" (Type 6 and Type 7, Table 10). The CM-MIC is a cryptographic digest created with cryptographic hashing function (e.g., Message Digest 5 ("MD5")) that ensures data sent from CM 16 is not modified en-route. CM-MIC is not an authenticated digest (i.e., it does not include any shared secret password). The CMTS-MIC is also a cryptographic digest used to authenticate configuration information. In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, a MD5 cryptographic hashing function is used to create the CM-MIC and CMTS-MIC digests as described in RFC-2104; incorporated herein by reference. However, other cryptographic hashing functions could also be used. As is known in the cryptography art, MD5 is a secure, one-way hashing function used to create a secure hash value that is used to authenticate messages. A CM-MIC value in a cable modem registration request message is calculated by performing an MD5 digest over the bytes of the TLV entries for the configuration information. However, in an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, a CM-MIC value includes the unique identifier (Table 11) and selected time-value (Table 12) that are added to the registration request message at steps 342 and 344 respectively of method 338, as well as one or more of the configuration parameters (Table 10). A CMTS-MIC value is calculated for a cable modem registration request message using the method shown in Table 15.
TABLE 15
CMTS-MIC field for a cable modem registration request message is
calculated by performing an MD5 digest over the following configuration
parameters fields, when present in the configuration
file, in the order shown:
.cndot.Downstream Frequency Configuration parameter
.cndot.Upstream Channel ID Configuration parameter
.cndot.Network Access Configuration parameter
.cndot.Class of Service Configuration parameter
.cndot.Vendor ID Configuration parameter
.cndot.Baseline Privacy Configuration parameters
.cndot.Vendor specific Configuration parameters
.cndot.CM-MIC value
.cndot.Authentication string.
The configuration parameters fields are treated as if they were contiguous
data when calculating the MD5 digest.
However, in an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, the CMTS-MIC value is calculated using the unique identifier (Table 11), the selected time-value (Table 12) and one or more configuration parameters (Table 10). In another embodiment of the present invention, a single MIC value is calculated using the unique identifier (Table 11) and the selected item value (Table 12). FIG. 21 is a flow diagram illustrating a method 368 to calculate a message integrity check value (e.g., at step 346 of method 336 or step 362 of method 352). At step 370, a first message check integrity value (e.g., CM-MIC) is calculated on one or more configuration parameters in a pre-determined order. The one or more configuration parameters include a unique identifier (Table 11) and a selected-time value (Table 12) and one or more other configuration parameters (Table 10). At step 372, the first message integrity check value is added to a first message (e.g., a registration request message). At step 374, a second message integrity check value (e.g., CMTS-MIC) is calculated on one or more configuration parameters and the first message integrity check value in a pre-determined order. The second message integrity check value is calculated using the unique identifier (Table 11), the selected-time value (Table 12), the first message integrity check value (e.g., CM-MIC), and one or more other configuration parameters (Table 10). In another embodiment of the present invention, the first and second message integrity check values are calculated using the unique identifier or the selected time-value and one or more configuration parameters in a pre-determined order. In yet another embodiment of the present invention, calculating the second message integrity includes the unique identifier or the selected time-value and one or more configuration parameters in a pre-determined order but does not include the first message integrity check value. In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, the first message integrity check value of method 368 is a CM-MIC, the second message integrity check value is a CMTS-MIC and the first message is a registration request message created by CM 16 (Tables 25 and 26) and sent to CMTS 12. However, other message integrity check values and message integrity calculations could also be used and the present invention is not limited to the CM-MIC and CMTS-MIC values and calculations. Table 16 illustrates step 374 of method 368 for an illustrative embodiment of the present invention. However, more or fewer configuration parameters and other orderings could also be used.
TABLE 16
1. Use the configuration parameters from the configuration file sent to
CM 16 as shown in Table 15 when present in the order listed.
2. Use the unique identifier, selected time-value and one or more of the
following additional configuration parameters and calculate a
CMTS-MIC value by performing an MD5 digest
Over the following configuration parameters, when present in the
registration request message, in the order shown:
.cndot. One or more configuration parameters (Table 10, Table 15).
.cndot. Selected time-value (Table 12)
.cndot. Unique identifier (Table 11)
.cndot. One or more configuration parameters (Table 10, Table 15).
Returning again to FIG. 20, at step 364, the message integrity check value (e.g., the CMTS-MIC value) is added to the registration request message. The message integrity check value includes the unique identifier and selected time value added at steps 358 and 360 of method 352 and one or more configuration parameters (Table 10). At step 366, the registration request message with the message integrity check value is sent from CM 16 to CMTS 12 via TRAC 24 and PSTN 22 on an upstream telephony connection. In another embodiment of the present invention, the registration request message is sent from CM 16 to CMTS 12 via cable network 14 on an upstream cable television connection. Cable modem registration request message 378 includes a UDP 60 source port field 380, a UDP 60 destination port field 382, a UDP 60 message length field 384, UDP 60 check sum field 386, a message type field 388 (1=registration request, 2=registration response), a CM 16 MAC 44 address field 390 and | ||||||
